Let’s Take the Fear Out of the Box

If you’ve been reading through the health testing drawers on our website, you may have spotted a little line that says “IVDD: 1 copy” and felt your heart skip a beat. I get it. The first time I saw that result on one of my own girls, I felt exactly the same way. I’ve had more than one family call me after reading an Embark report late at night, worried sick that their sweet puppy was headed for a wheelchair.

So grab a cup of coffee and let’s talk about it, breeder to family, with nothing tucked under the rug.

I’m not a geneticist and I’m not a veterinarian. What I am is a breeder of more than 35 years who has spent countless hours reading the research, sitting through vet symposiums, talking with my own vets, and asking a lot of hard questions. I’ve put links to the universities and veterinary schools all through this post, and there’s a full list at the end. Please click them. I would much rather you trust the science than just take my word for it.

Here’s the short version before we dig in. IVDD is a real disease, and it can be a serious one. The gene linked to it is common in a lot of breeds, including a couple of the breeds behind our doodles. But having the gene and getting the disease are two very different things, and the dogs who get sick most often are built very differently from a Bernedoodle or a Double Doodle.

First Things First: What Is IVDD?

Your dog’s spine is a long chain of small bones called vertebrae. Between each pair sits a disc that works like a shock absorber. I like to picture a jelly donut: a tough, fibrous outer ring with a soft, gel-like center. That soft center is what lets the back bend, twist, and soak up every leap off the porch steps.

Intervertebral disc disease, or IVDD, is what happens when those discs break down. A weakened disc can bulge or burst and press on the spinal cord. That pressure is what causes the pain, the wobbly walking, and in the worst cases, paralysis.

Diagram of a dog's spine showing a healthy disc and a bulging disc in IVDD

Vets talk about two main types, and the difference really matters for our conversation:

  • Type I (Hansen Type I). The jelly center dries out and hardens early in life, sometimes before a dog is a year old. Later, an everyday jump or twist makes it burst through the outer ring, and the signs come on suddenly. This is the type tied to the gene on your Embark report. It’s the one you hear about in Dachshunds, Corgis, Beagles and French Bulldogs.
  • Type II (Hansen Type II). A slow bulge that builds over years, usually in older, larger dogs like Labs and German Shepherds. It’s more like the “bad back” so many of us humans get with age, and it is not what the CDDY gene test is about.

The American College of Veterinary Surgeons says the short-legged, long-bodied breeds account for the vast majority of all disc ruptures, with the Dachshund alone making up 45 to 70 percent of cases. In those breeds, signs usually start between 3 and 6 years old. In larger, longer-legged dogs, disc trouble usually shows up later, between 5 and 12. Most ruptures happen in the middle and lower back, and fewer in the neck. (ACVS: Intervertebral Disc Disease)

The Gene Behind the Headlines: CDDY

In 2017, researchers in the Bannasch Lab at the University of California, Davis found the piece of DNA behind most Type I IVDD. It’s an extra copy of a gene called FGF4 that got tucked into a new spot on chromosome 12. Geneticists call it CDDY, short for chondrodystrophy. On Embark you’ll see it listed as Intervertebral Disc Disease (Type I), or CDDY/IVDD. (The original 2017 study in PNAS)

So what does that extra copy actually do? FGF4 is a growth signal that helps build the legs and the spine while a puppy is still developing. UC Davis found that the extra copy makes about ten times more of that signal inside the disc. The soft center of every disc starts drying out and hardening while the dog is young, and those changed discs are more likely to burst later on. In dogs with two copies, researchers could see the changes as early as 10 weeks old, and they were missing in dogs of the same breed without the gene. (UC Davis: Managing the Genetics of Chondrodystrophy)

The same gene also shortens the legs a little, which is how it was found in the first place, by studying short-legged breeds. Dogs with two copies have shorter legs than dogs with one. In a 50-pound Bernedoodle with one copy, you would never notice.

There’s a second short-leg gene you might read about, called CDPA, on chromosome 18. That’s a big part of what gives Corgis and Basset Hounds their famous little legs, but it is not linked to IVDD risk, and Embark doesn’t test for it. Please don’t let the two get mixed up. (UC Davis VGL: CDDY and CDPA test)

Why we no longer say “carrier”

On our Parents page you may have read “IVDD Carrier.” That’s the word breeders have used for years, but it isn’t quite right, and I’d rather be accurate with you.

A carrier normally means a dog has one copy of a recessive gene, like Degenerative Myelopathy, and isn’t at risk itself. CDDY works differently. For disc changes it is dominant, which means one copy is enough. UC Davis says a dog with one copy has the changed discs and is at risk for a disc herniation, the same as a dog with two. So from now on, we’ll say a dog has “one copy” or “two copies.”

Here’s what one copy does not mean. It doesn’t mean your dog has the painful disease, and it doesn’t mean your dog will ever get it. Embark points out that even in breeds where nearly every dog has this gene, like Beagles and Cocker Spaniels, many of those dogs never develop IVDD. Wisdom Panel, another big DNA company, says the same thing: many at-risk dogs never develop the condition. (Wisdom Panel: CDDY and IVDD Risk)

Taking the Lid Off the Box a Little Too Soon

Now I’m going to put my breeder hat on and tell you how all of this felt from my side of the whelping box.

The discovery itself is a wonderful thing. Knowing which dogs have this gene helps good breeders make smarter pairings, and I’m truly grateful for it. What was hard was how fast it landed in every at-home DNA kit. Almost overnight, families were opening reports with “at risk” printed next to their brand new puppy’s name, and very little explanation of what that meant for a long-legged, mixed-breed family dog.

If I’m honest, I wish the geneticists had waited until they understood the whole picture before they took the lid off that box. A lot of wonderful families, and a lot of careful breeders, got frightened by something that, for dogs built like ours, is still far more question than answer. Because here’s the thing… there are still a lot of questions.

  • Almost all of the research has been done in short-legged breeds. I have searched and searched, and I haven’t found one published study that measures how often IVDD actually happens in Bernedoodles or Double Doodles. I wish I could hand you a number. Right now, nobody can.
  • Scientists still don’t agree on what one copy versus two really means. UC Davis treats CDDY as dominant for disc risk, so in their research a dog with two copies wasn’t shown to be any more likely to have a disc problem than a dog with one. In 2025, researchers at Auburn University looked at the discs on X-rays in Dachshunds with zero, one and two copies, and the dogs with one copy had spine scores about as good as dogs with no copies at all. It was one breed and only a handful of dogs, so it isn’t the final word, but it’s one more sign that a copy of this gene isn’t the whole story. (Auburn University breeder summary)
  • The gene isn’t the whole story. In the big UC Davis study of dogs who needed back surgery, about three out of four had CDDY, which means about one in four did not. Other genes, most of them still unknown, plus body shape, weight, activity and plain old age all play a part. Embark says this too: the gene alone doesn’t decide whether a dog gets sick, and on its own it isn’t a reason to pull a dog from a breeding program. (Embark: What Is a Linkage Test?)

So when you see “1 copy” in one of our drawers, please read it the way the scientists mean it: a piece of information that helps us breed wisely, not a diagnosis.

So Where Does the Gene Come From in Our Doodles?

This is where it gets interesting, and where a lot of the fear can start to melt away.

UC Davis measured how often the CDDY gene shows up in dozens of breeds. They report it as an “allele frequency.” Don’t let the term scare you. A number of 0 means nobody tested had it, a number of 1.00 means every dog tested had two copies, and 0.57 means roughly 57 out of every 100 copies of that spot in the breed carry it. Here are the breeds that make up Cloud Nine’s Bernedoodles and Double Doodles:

Breed behind our doodlesHow often the CDDY gene showed up (0 to 1.00)Dogs tested
Bernese Mountain Dog011
Standard Poodle055
Golden Retriever014
Labrador Retriever021
Australian Shepherd0.0246
Miniature and Toy Poodle0.57114
American Cocker Spaniel0.949

Source: UC Davis, Managing the Genetics of Chondrodystrophy, adapted from Batcher and colleagues, 2019. Some of these groups are small, so think of them as a snapshot, not the last word.

Josie, a Bernese Mountain Dog, lying beside her Bernedoodle puppy Daisy at Cloud Nine Doodles

Do you see what jumps out? The big, long-legged breeds in our lines, the Bernese, the Standard Poodle, the Golden and the Lab, barely have this gene at all. Where it shows up is in the smaller Poodles and in the Cocker Spaniel.

That lines up exactly with what we see in our own dogs. Our full Bernese girls are clear. The one copies show up in our smaller Double Doodles, who have both small Poodle and Cocker Spaniel in their family trees, and in our multigenerational and mini Bernedoodles, where small Poodle was used to bring the size down. A classic standard Bernedoodle, Bernese crossed with Standard Poodle, is very unlikely to have it at all.

So yes, the gene does show up in doodles, and I won’t pretend it doesn’t. Which brings us to the most important question of all.

Having the Gene vs. Getting the Disease

This is the part that matters most, so let’s go slow.

The “5 to 15 times” number

If you click through to UC Davis, you’ll read that dogs with one or two copies of CDDY were 5 to 15 times more likely to have a disc herniate than dogs without it. You’ll also see that the highest number in that study, about 15 times, was in mixed-breed dogs. I’m not going to hide that from you. It’s right there on the page, and you deserve to see it.

But here’s what “times more likely” really means. It’s a multiplier, and a multiplier only tells you something once you know the starting number. If something happens to very few dogs to begin with, even several times that is still not many. If it happens to one in four dogs, the same multiplier is a whole different story. The researchers were also clear that among dogs who did need surgery, plenty had only one copy, mixed breeds included. One copy isn’t a free pass. It just isn’t a sentence either.

What the real-world numbers look like

The biggest study I’ve found on how often disc disease happens comes from Sweden, where researchers went through insurance records for more than 665,000 dogs. Across all breeds, disc-related disease came to about 28 cases per 10,000 dogs per year, or roughly 3 dogs in every 1,000 each year. Miniature Dachshunds, the highest-risk breed, came in at about 237 per 10,000. (Bergknut and colleagues, 2012, JAVMA)

Compare that with Dachshunds. A survey of more than 2,000 of them found about 1 in 6 had been diagnosed with IVDD, and older estimates put the lifetime number closer to 1 in 4 or 1 in 5. (DachsLife 2015 study) That’s the kind of risk people picture when they hear “IVDD,” and it simply isn’t the picture for a dog built like a doodle.

Why body shape matters so much

A team at the Royal Veterinary College in England measured dogs of many different breeds. The longer a dog’s back was compared to its height, the higher its risk of a disc bursting in the back. Extra body weight raised the risk too. (Packer and colleagues, 2013, “How Long and Low Can You Go?”)

Side view of a Cloud Nine doodle showing a square, long-legged build

Now picture our doodles. Bernedoodles and Double Doodles are athletic, square, leggy dogs, with backs about as long as they are tall. That’s a world away from the long-and-low shape that puts Dachshunds, Corgis and Basset Hounds at the top of every IVDD list. It’s also why I believe, from everything I’ve read and from 35 years with these dogs, that IVDD risk for our Bernedoodles and Double Doodles is low. Low isn’t zero, and I’ll never tell you it is. But it’s low.

What We Do About It at Cloud Nine

When I first saw CDDY on one of my girls’ reports, I was concerned. But after a lot of research, long talks with my vets and hours of vet symposiums, it became clear that the experts don’t recommend pulling every dog with a copy. In fact, they recommend almost the opposite, and here’s why.

We test every breeding dog. Every Cloud Nine mom and dad goes through Embark’s full disease and traits panel, along with hips, elbows, patellas, heart and eyes. Every result is posted in that dog’s Health Testing drawer for you to see, including the ones that aren’t perfect.

We try hard never to pair two dogs who both have CDDY. Whenever we can, a dog with one copy is paired with a dog with zero copies, and when you do that, each puppy has about a 50/50 chance of getting one copy. Because this gene is so common across the whole doodle gene pool, weeding it out of our lines takes years, and the perfect match isn’t always possible. Thankfully, the research so far hasn’t shown a dog with two copies to be any more likely to show signs of IVDD than a dog with one. (OFA: CDDY/IVDD)

Cloud Nine Doodles mom nursing her health-tested litter

We’re breeding it down slowly, on purpose. UC Davis gives breeders clear advice. When the gene is common in a population, pair dogs who have it with dogs who don’t, and lower it over several generations instead of throwing out good dogs all at once. Cornell University’s canine health center says the same: look at the whole dog, its temperament, its hips and elbows, its family history, not one test on its own. Cutting every dog with one copy would shrink the gene pool, and a smaller gene pool brings its own health problems. (Cornell Riney Canine Health Center: CDDY/IVDD)

Our goal is to breed this gene out of our program over the next several generations, while keeping the wonderful temperaments, health and coats our families love. To date, we’ve never had a Cloud Nine dog or puppy show signs of IVDD, and honestly, I don’t expect we ever will. I don’t know of a single doodle breeder who has, either. It just isn’t something we’re seeing on the ground. In fact, the ALAA (Australian Labradoodle Association of America) is running a big member survey right now to find out how many of their breeders have ever seen it. A lot of us feel this gene has been turned into a big, sticky mess before even the geneticists fully understand it, and I’m looking forward to seeing what that survey shows.

We wait on spay and neuter. Our puppy contract asks families to spay or neuter between 1 and 1.5 years old. That was decided for joint and growth-plate reasons, but there’s an IVDD connection too. In a study of nearly 2,000 Dachshunds, dogs spayed or neutered before 12 months had a higher risk of disc herniation than those done later. That’s Dachshund data, not doodle data, but it’s one more reason we feel good about waiting. (Neuter status and IVDH in Dachshunds, 2018)

What You Can Do at Home

Here’s the good news. The things that protect your doodle’s back are the same things that keep them healthy in every other way. No special equipment, no fancy program, just good everyday habits.

Cloud Nine doodle puppy sitting on a rock at a mountain lake on a hike
  • Keep them lean. This is the big one. Extra weight puts extra strain on every disc, and it showed up as a risk factor in the research. Run your hands down your dog’s back and sides every week. You should feel the spine and ribs easily under a thin layer of padding. If you can’t, cut back a little (our Complete Guide to Canine Nutrition walks you through how).
  • Keep them moving every day. Strong muscles support the spine. In the big Dachshund survey, dogs who got less than 30 minutes of exercise a day had higher odds of IVDD. A survey can’t prove cause and effect, but daily walks on level ground are good medicine for any dog.
  • Think about ramps and steps. Cornell recommends steps or ramps to cut down on jumping on and off high beds, couches and the back of the car. This matters most for our smaller doodles and for any dog as they get older.
  • Lift with both hands. When you pick up your doodle, support the chest and the back end together, so the spine stays level. Never lift a dog by the front legs or under the armpits alone.
  • Use a harness for walks. A well-fitted harness takes pressure off the neck. Cornell mentions harnesses, including front-clip styles, as a lower-stress option.
  • Wait on spay and neuter until 1 to 1.5 years old, as our contract asks.
  • Keep pet insurance in place. Activate your free Trupanion coverage on go-home day and think seriously about keeping a policy. Spinal surgery is an emergency surgery, and it isn’t cheap. Insurance means you never have to choose between your dog and your bank account.

What about joint supplements? Cornell says omega fatty acids, glucosamine and chondroitin may offer some benefit, but there haven’t been trials to prove it for discs. Ask your vet what makes sense for your dog.

Signs to Watch For, and What to Do

I hope you never need this section, but I want every Cloud Nine family to know these signs by heart. Catching a disc problem early makes a huge difference. Watch for:

  • Not wanting to jump up, or go up or down stairs
  • Yelping when picked up, petted along the back, or touched on the neck
  • A hunched or arched back, or a stiff neck held low
  • Shaking or trembling, panting, or seeming restless with no clear reason
  • Wobbly, “drunk” walking, or back legs that cross or sway
  • Knuckling, where the top of a back paw scuffs or drags on the ground
  • Weakness in the back legs, or not being able to stand
  • Trouble peeing or pooping, or accidents from a dog who never has them

If your dog suddenly can’t walk or is dragging their back legs, go to the vet or an emergency hospital right away. Don’t wait until morning. Surgeons treat a ruptured disc with paralysis as an emergency, and time matters. (ACVS)

There’s real hope even in a bad case. Washington State University’s veterinary hospital says that if a dog can still feel its legs, even when it can’t move them, there’s an 80 to 85 percent chance it will walk again after surgery. (WSU Veterinary Teaching Hospital) Milder cases are often treated with strict crate rest and pain medicine prescribed by your vet. Please never give your dog human pain relievers.

And of course, call me. I’m always here for you, for the life of your dog.

Read for Yourself

I promised you links, and here they are. I’ve grouped them so you can start with the easy reads and dig as deep as you like.

Easy-to-read overviews

About the gene and the DNA test

The research papers

If you find something new, please send it my way. I keep learning right alongside you.

The Bottom Line

Two sleepy Cloud Nine Bernedoodle puppies   Cloud Nine Doodles

IVDD is real, and I take it seriously. That’s exactly why we test every dog, show you every result, and pair our dogs so carefully. But a “1 copy” on a doodle’s report is not a diagnosis, and it’s not a reason to lose sleep. The gene came into some of our lines through the smaller Poodles and the Cocker Spaniel. The disease mostly strikes dogs built long and low. And the science on what one copy really means for a square, leggy doodle is still being written.

In the meantime, keep your pup lean, keep them moving, give them a ramp when they need one, and know the warning signs. That’s good care for any dog, IVDD or not.

If you have questions, I’m always happy to talk. You can reply to any of our emails or schedule a call with me here. No question is too small.

Have a happy, healthy, Doodle-Kind-a-Day!

Sally Powell
Cloud Nine Doodles, Lynden, WA

author avatar
Sally Powell
Sally Powell is the founder of Cloud Nine Doodles in Lynden, Washington, with more than 35 years of experience breeding and raising dogs. She grew up in a breeder’s home, raised her own children in 4-H, and now raises health-tested Bernedoodles and Double Doodles in her family home using Early Neurological Stimulation, Puppy Culture and Volhard temperament testing. Her puppies have gone on to become therapy and first-responder peer-support dogs. She writes to help doodle families raise healthy, happy, well-trained companions.
error: Content is protected !!